Featured Image
Beyond the Obvious Candidates

Key Takeaways

Sponsorship, non-linear careers, and why the people who open doors matter as much as the people who enter the establishment. This is a Women In Energy Spotlight.

Few parts of the energy business attract as much attention as the trading desk. Jacqui Pynn, Head of Desk at Harbour Energy, says that it is where everyone wants to send their work experience students, and where graduates most want to rotate. Getting in is hard for anybody, and Pynn is the first to say that isn’t a story about gender.

Where gender does come in, she says, is visibility. Few women are visible in senior leadership, which makes it harder for women to picture themselves in those roles. It can also be harder to build the networks and sponsors that careers depend on. In her words, “It’s about having people to advocate for you.”

The detour that became an advantage

Pynn’s own route into the market was not a conventional one. She didn’t set out to trade and, by her own account, didn’t know what it was. She was in an aerospace role when she began applying for FTSE 100 commercial opportunities, and someone in the trading arm of a major energy company brought her into market risk on the strength of her potential.

What followed was persistence and some self-advocacy, plus two sponsors who put her forward at key moments. That first saw her transferable skill set. The second, years later, saw them again and moved her from middle office to front office, resisting the tendency to pigeonhole people by function. Many traders are warned that a start in middle office will leave them stuck. Pynn found her background outside trading gave her an end-to-end view of the value chain.

Her conclusion is that “careers don’t have to be linear.” She now sends people she is developing for the front office to spend time in other parts of the business with the aim of giving them that same advantage. It’s a precedence that other senior leaders can easily follow, with the benefit of expanding the acumen of their juniors.

Culture as a choice

Throughout her career, Pynn has chosen organisations on trust, flexibility, and culture. She is candid that this involved trade-offs against pay. She puts that partly down to pressures outside work, and doesn’t claim to separate what is specific to women from what is general.

What she values in her own firm is that it looks at performance and outcomes, rather than presence. Her catchphrase at work: “Work is something you do. It is not somewhere you go.” The technology exists to run an efficient desk with flexible and hybrid working, and a rigid desk rules out part of the talent pool. Many front offices are back to five days a week, and she says presence is still treated as a badge of honour. The side effect is quiet: people with families may opt-out of applying for a role due to rigid attendance expectations. That is something senior leaders can easily influence.

What hiring managers can do

Pynn’s advice to people who build teams is specific: Push for a balanced candidate pool, and do it every time. She does this herself, and says her pools for front-office roles are still weaker than she would like. She understands why: in specialist areas, the female talent pool is relatively small. But if hiring managers don’t “look beyond the obvious candidates”, progress will stay slow.

She also sees the other side. Someone running a desk wants a proven track record, and an excellent candidate from a different industry may not get the necessary internal buy-in for hire. On her reading of the market: “analytical and execution roles are doing reasonably okay, but strategic decision-making leadership positions are still pretty poor for diversity.”

Progress at its own pace

The progress is there. More accomplished women are leading trading teams, managing portfolios, and running businesses. The need has shifted, Pynn says, from general diversity needs to senior-level leadership roles. Her assessment is measured: the market is “moving in the right direction — extraordinarily slowly.”


Jacqui Pynn is the Head of Desk at Harbour Energy.


Looking for more insights? This conversation is part of our Women in Energy Spotlight. Get exclusive insights from industry leaders, stay up-to-date with the latest news, and explore the cutting-edge tech shaping the sector by subscribing to our newsletter.

Featuring insights from

Avatar photo
Jacqui Pynn

Jacqui Pynn is the Head of Desk at Harbour Energy.

Read more blogs

Ask for the Mentor You Haven’t Been Offered

In renewables origination leadership, Lena Lehmeier can count the women at her level on one hand. At conferences,...

Read more

Nilesh Khatri on Commodities Technology, Trust, and What Gets Missed...

Sydney and London: two very different markets. Rarely do commodities leaders get an intimate view inside both. Twenty-five...

Read more

“Not a Burden on the Grid”: Pete Aynge on Building...

The conversation around data centres and the grid usually runs one way. Power demand is rising at a...

Read more

David Garrett on AI Ambition vs. Organisational Trust

Most enterprises entered 2026 believing they had an AI strategy. David Garrett, a data and AI advisor with...

Read more